Finding the right English tutor for your child’s IGCSE can feel overwhelming. The market is flooded with options — agency-listed tutors, freelance profiles, online platforms — and the quality varies enormously. This checklist will help you cut through the noise and find someone who will actually make a difference.
1. Do They Actually Know the IGCSE English Exam?
This sounds obvious, but it’s the most common pitfall. A tutor can be an excellent English teacher without knowing the specific demands of the IGCSE papers. IGCSE English Language Paper 1 and Paper 2 have very particular question types — summary writing, directed writing, language analysis — that require specific, practised techniques.
Ask: “Can you walk me through the structure of IGCSE English Language Paper 1?” A good tutor will answer fluently and specifically. Vague answers about “building reading comprehension skills” suggest they don’t know the exam inside out.
2. Do They Have Experience Teaching This Exam Board?
Cambridge IGCSE, Edexcel IGCSE, and CIE are not all the same. The question types, mark schemes, and assessment objectives differ between boards. A tutor who knows Cambridge IGCSE well may be unfamiliar with the nuances of the Edexcel version — so check which board your child is sitting, and confirm the tutor knows it specifically.
Former examiners — teachers who have actually marked the exams — are particularly valuable here. They know precisely what gains marks and what doesn’t, in a way that no amount of revision guide reading can replicate.
3. What Does a Typical Session Look Like?
Good tutors can describe a session in specific terms: “We’d spend 20 minutes on a timed comprehension question, then go through it together using the mark scheme, then I’d give feedback on how to improve the answer structure.” Vague answers — “it depends on the student,” “we work on whatever they need” — can be a sign of a tutor who improvises rather than teaches with purpose.
This doesn’t mean sessions should be rigid, but there should be a clear pedagogical approach behind the flexibility.
4. Do They Provide Written Feedback on Essays?
English is a written exam. If your child’s tutor isn’t reading and responding in detail to their written work, something is missing. Marking an essay takes time — it can’t be done properly during a session. Ask whether the tutor marks extended writing between sessions and provides written comments that students can refer back to.
This is also how good tutors build a picture of the student’s specific weaknesses over time, rather than treating every session as a fresh start.
5. What Is Their Group Size?
If they offer group tuition, how many students are in each group? A group of 12 is not a small group — it’s a class. A group of 4–6 is genuinely intimate: every student’s work gets read, every student’s questions get answered, and the tutor can differentiate between students who are struggling with structure and students who struggle with analysis.
Ask how the tutor handles students at different levels within the same group. A good answer involves adapting feedback and questions to the individual — not simply pitching everything at the middle of the room.
6. Can They Provide References or Evidence of Results?
Not every tutor will have a long list of public testimonials, particularly if they’re new to private tutoring. But they should be able to tell you something concrete: students who improved by X grades, specific challenges they’ve helped students overcome, or former students who are willing to speak with you.
Be sceptical of very general claims (“all my students get top grades”) but don’t write off someone honest enough to say “I’ve worked with five IGCSE students and I can point you to two of their parents.”
7. Is There a Trial Session?
Any good tutor should be willing to offer a trial lesson. This matters for two reasons: it lets you assess the quality of teaching before committing, and it lets you see whether your child connects with the tutor’s style. Chemistry between student and teacher is real and important — a technically excellent tutor who your child finds boring or intimidating won’t deliver the results a slightly less experienced tutor with real rapport can achieve.
Sit in on part of the trial session if possible, or ask your child specific questions afterwards: Did they explain things clearly? Did they feel comfortable asking questions? Did they come away feeling more confident or more confused?
Red Flags to Watch Out For
- No specific knowledge of the exam — can’t describe the paper structure or question types
- Large groups (10+ students) marketed as “small group tutoring”
- No written feedback on essays — feedback only given verbally during sessions
- Inability to give specific examples of their teaching approach
- Pressure to commit to a long block of sessions before a trial
- Claims of guaranteed results or specific grades
Thorogood English offers a free trial lesson before you commit to anything. Jacqueline is a qualified teacher with experience as a Cambridge examiner, and groups are capped at six students. Join the waiting list for January 2027 classes — or get in touch with any questions.